Advice

Forest Degradation

There are five broad levels of degradation, each of which requires a different restoration strategy. They can be distinguished by recognising six critical ‘thresholds’ of degradation; three pertain to the site being restored and three to the surrounding landscape.

Site-critical thresholds:

  • The density of trees is reduced such that herbaceous weeds dominate the site and suppress tree seedling establishment
  • On-site sources of forest regeneration (i.e. the seed or seedling bank, live stumps, seed trees etc.) decline below the levels needed to maintain viable populations of climax forest tree species.
  • Soil degradation has proceeded to such an extent that poor soil conditions limit the establishment of tree seedlings.

Landscape-critical thresholds:

  • There are only small and sparse remnants of climax forest in the landscape, such that the diversity of tree species within dispersal distance of the forest restoration site is not sufficient to represent the climax forest.
  • Populations of seed-dispersing animals are reduced to the point that seeds are no longer transported to the forest restoration site in sufficiently high densities to reestablish all of the required tree species.
  • Fire risk is increased such that naturally established trees are unlikely to survive because of the increased cover of combustible herbaceous weeds in the landscape immediately surrounding the restoration site.
                                                                                  SITE-CRITICAL                                  LANDSCAPE-CRITICAL
STAGE-1 DEGRADATION

stage1

Vegetation : Trees dominate over herbaceous weeds
Sources of regeneration : Plentiful: soil seed bank viable; dense seedling bank; dense seed rain; live tree stumps
Soil : Little localised disturbance; remains mostly fertile
Forest : Large remnants remain as seed sources
Seed dispersers : Common; both large and small species
Fire risk : Low to medium
RECOMMENDED RESTORATION STRATEGY:
  • Protection from encroachment, cattle, fire and any other further disturbances and prevention of
    the hunting of seed-dispersing animals
  • Re-introduction of locally extirpated species
                                                                                 SITE-CRITICAL                                  LANDSCAPE-CRITICAL
STAGE-2 DEGRADATION

stage2

Vegetation : Mixed trees and
herbaceous weeds
Sources of regeneration : Seeds and seedling banks depleted live tree stumps common
Soil : Remains mostly fertile: erosion low
Forest : Remnants remain as seed sources
Seed dispersers : Large species becoming rare, but small species still common
Fire risk : Medium to high
RECOMMENDED RESTORATION STRATEGY:
  • Protection + ANR
  • Re-introduction of locally extirpated species
                                                                                SITE-CRITICAL                                  LANDSCAPE-CRITICAL
STAGE-3 DEGRADATION

stage3

Vegetation : Herbaceous weeds dominate
Sources of regeneration : Mostly from incoming seed rain; a few saplings and live stumps might remain
Soil : Remains mostly fertile; erosion low
Forest :  Remnants remain as seed sources
Seed dispersers : Mostly small species dispersing small seeds
Fire risk : High
RECOMMENDED RESTORATION STRATEGY:
  • Site protection + ANR + planting framework species
                                                                               SITE-CRITICAL                                  LANDSCAPE-CRITICAL
STAGE-4 DEGRADATION

stage4

Vegetation : Herbaceous weeds dominate
Sources of regeneration : Low
Soil : Erosion risk increasing
Forest : Remnants too few or too distant to disperse tree seed to site
Seed dispersers : Mostly gone
Fire risk : High
RECOMMENDED RESTORATION STRATEGY:
  • Site protection + ANR + planting framework species + enrichment planting with climax species
  • Maximum diversity methods such as the Miyawaki method
                                                                                SITE-CRITICAL                                  LANDSCAPE-CRITICAL
STAGE-5 DEGRADATION

stage5

Vegetation : No tree cover. Poor soil might limit growth of herbaceous weeds
Sources of regeneration : Very few or none
Soil : Poor soil conditions limit tree establishment
Forest : Usually absent within seed dispersal distances of the site
Seed dispersers : Mostly gone
Fire risk : Initially low (soil conditions limit plant growth); higher as the vegetation recovers
RECOMMENDED RESTORATION STRATEGY:
  • Soil improvement by planting green mulches and the addition of compost, fertilisers or soil microorganisms
  • followed by planting ‘nurse trees’ — i.e. hardy nitrogen-fixing trees that will further improve
    the soil (also known as the “plantations as catalysts” method)
  • then thinning of nurse trees and their gradual replacement by planting a wide range of
    native forest tree species
Duration:  - 
Comprises 3 initiatives: i) "From Bare Mountains to Regenerated Forest"; ii) "Forest Landscape Restoration and Community Well-being" and iii) "Evaluating Changes and Ecosystem Services in Nan's Restored Forests; testing the framework species method of forest restoration in Nan's highly fragmented landscape. Tree diversity, density & phenology and bird diversity are compared between restored sites and reference forest. Results are shared with local communities and the project's impact on livelihoods assessed.

1: ทฤษฎีเบื้องหลังการฟื้นฟู

Publication dateOct 2023
Author(s)พนิตนาถ แชนนอน
PublisherFORRU-CMU
Format
Book

หนังสือเล่มนี้ได้รวบรวมเนื้อหาครอบคลุมถึงการรบกวนที่ส่งผลต่อกระบวนการฟื้นตัวของธรรมชาติ ทำให้มวลชีวภาพลดลงและสภาพดินเปลี่ยนแปลงไป...

2: Use of drone RGB imagery to quantify indicator variables of tropical-forest-ecosystem degradation and restoration  

Publication date16 Mar 2023
Author(s)Lee, K.; Elliott, S.; Tiansawat, P.
PublisherForests
Format
Journal Paper

ABSTRACT: Recognizing initial degradation levels is essential to planning effective measures to restore tropical forest ecosystems. However, measuring indicators of forest degradation is...

3: Multi-Scenario Simulations of Future Forest Cover Changes Influenced by Socio-Economic Development: A Case Study in the Chiang Mai-Lamphun Basin

Publication date16 Aug 2022
Author(s)Rachata Arunsurat, Prasit Wangpakapattanawong, Alice Sharp, Watit Khokthong
PublisherEnvironmentAsia
Format
Journal Paper

Abstract: Changes in land cover in the Chiang Mai-Lamphun basin have been influenced by pressures of rapid socio-economic developments. The Markov-cellular automata and a multi-layer perceptron...

4: UAV-derived forest degradation assessments for planning and monitoring forest ecosystem restoration: towards a forest degradation index

Publication dateNov 2021
Author(s)Kyuho Lee
PublisherCGIAR Research Program on Forests, Trees and Agroforestry and Rome, Italy: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.
Format
Conference Paper

ABSTRACT: Global initiatives such as the Bonn Challenge and the New York Declaration on Forests have prompted large-scale forest restoration projects to combat land degradation, preserve...

5: Soil bacterial communities and their associated functions for forest restoration on a limestone mine in northern Thailand

Publication date08 Apr 2021
Author(s)Sansupa, C., W. Purahong, T. Wubet, P. Tiansawat, W. Pathom-Aree, N. Teaumroong, P. Chantawannakul, F. Buscot, S. Elliott & T. Disayathanoowat
PublisherPLoS ONE
Format
Journal Paper

ABSTRACT: Opencast mining removes topsoil and associated bacterial communities that play crucial roles in soil ecosystem functioning. Understanding the community composition and functioning of...

6: Comparison of Soil Microbial Communities in Opencast Limestone Mine and Mine Rehabilitation Sites

Publication date2021
Author(s)Chakriya Sansupa
PublisherThe Graduate School, Chiang Mai University
Format
PhD Thesis

Opencast mining is considered as an extreme form of land degradation, requiring an intensive array of rehabilitation practices. The mine rehabilitation practice, in the semiopencast limestone mine...

7: Developing a Forest-Degradation Index for Forest Ecosystem Restoration Using UAV-based RGB Photography

Publication date2021
Author(s)Kyuho Lee
PublisherThe Graduate School, Chiang Mai University
Format
MSc Thesis

Abstract: Forest degradation assessment is essential to plan restoration. This study was a first attempt to develop a forest-degradation index (FDI), based on data from unmanned aerial vehicles...

8: A trait-based approach for selecting tree species for aerial seeding

Publication date2020
Author(s)Beckman, N.G. & P. Tiansawat
Editors(s)Elliott S., G, Gale & M. Robertson
PublisherFORRU-CMU
Format
Conference Paper

ABSTRACT: We review recent ecological research on functional traits that can aid selection of tree species for restoration by aerial seeding. A major barrier in selecting species for restoration...

9: Diversity of Ground Flora in Restoration Area of The Siam Cement (Lampang) Co., Ltd Limestone Quarry

Publication date2019
Author(s)Pornpawee Laohasom
PublisherChiang Mai University
Format
BSc Project

 Ground flora communities in framework species method restoration area of Siam cement (Lampang) Co. Ltd. limestone quarries were studied. adding top soil with the value of 2.81, 2.50 and 1.99,...

10: Seed and microsite limitations of large-seeded, zoochorous trees in tropical forest restoration plantations in northern Thailand

Publication date2018
Author(s)Sangsupan, H., D. Hibbs, B. Withrow-Robinson & S. Elliott
PublisherElsevier: Forest Ecology and Management 419-420:91-100
Format
Journal Paper

ABSTRACT: On deforested or degraded land, planting mixtures of native forest tree species facilitates establishment of incoming tree seedling species (i.e. "species recruitment") by rapidly...